Birnie Thos R & Sons Ltd

Plumbing
Hamilton ON L8E
Write a Review
Write a Review

Recommended Professionals

99%(10 reviews)
98%(28 reviews)
98%(28 reviews)
99%(10 reviews)
98%(28 reviews)
98%(28 reviews)
HomeStars
Plumbing
Birnie Thos R & Sons Ltd
Star Score
Learn more about how StarScore uses a complex algorithm which considers a company's review ratings, responsiveness, reputation, and recency.

79%

This is the average rating based on homeowner reviews.
This indicates how long it's been since the last review.
Indicates how well a pro reacts to reviews and review-related interactions with Homeowners.
How well a company responds to Service Requests and Reviews.
Reviews by rating (past 12 months)

Reviews for Birnie Thos R & Sons Ltd

Average customer rating:
8.2 10 (87 reviews)

Sort by

lian f from Hamilton
lian f from Hamilton
2 reviews Mississauga, ON
1/10

pipe switch

I hate this company. I hate poor customer service. - Booked a full day for a lead to copper pipe change. They called the day before to cancel, after I had already booked off work, informed child's school and daycare, to say that someone didn't have water and that meant I wouldn't get serviced. - Gave me an "all in" quote that wasn't itemized, then when I found out I didn't have to pay for the more expensive permit, told me I wouldn't get my money back. - The men who actually did the job (2 of them) were very nice, skilled and as fast as they could be. - I was told that if the ground sank after they refilled the 8 foot hole in my front yard, to call and they would come and refill it. The ground DID sink 6 weeks later after a few days of heavy rain, so much that my concrete porch support became unstable and started falling into the hole that they had dug right in front of it. Also the valve was sticking slightly above the ground. When I called them to ask them to fill the hole and please lift the concrete support before doing so, I was told a note was made and I heard NOTHING back for a week. I called again and was told it would be taken care of and then heard NOTHING again. Left a message. NOTHING. when I finally got annoyed after THREE weeks, I called and got slightly irritated. what I got in result was some tools coming to my house and throwing a pile of dirt over the sunken area AND my porch support which I had specifically asked three times for them to raise before they filled the hole. I called again to complain about having to go and dig this out myself despite making clear requests that the support be returned to it's previous state and still heard nothing back. After another few weeks I began to ask for someone higher up in the company to deal with and spoke with the manger. He also was not the best at returning my calls, and apologized profusely for "forgetting" when he promised me the work would finally be done, but it wasn't. After that final straw, and also calling him on his company cell quite a few times with no response I informed them that I no longer had any patience after over 3 months of waiting and would file a claim to recoup my money to have someone else come and fix my porch and my toilet. The work was promised the next week and was done.

Part of the quote was for them to fix a toilet in my basement. The men who came had NO idea they were supposed to fix the toilet. When I asked them what the problem was, they said it was just "switched off". I the fool, believed them and didn't check. Now I just realized that the toilet is STILL not working and I'll have to call these people back (this makes probably more than 6 calls now) to come and do this properly too. When the plumber came he informed me that the men who were there previously were not plumbers and so would not have been able to assess and repair the toilet properly (which was nice to find out after the fact). He fixed the problem in less than 15 minutes and to their credit, the parts were free as I had waited for FOUR months after my original quote date to get this done.

I told the manager in no uncertain terms how disgusting I felt their treatment of me as a customer, and a business owner myself, was when it was their policy to do the job properly and quickly. He was understanding and both apologized and sent a card after the work was done.

I had read bad reviews about this company and decided to take my chances since they're the "largest" in Hamilton and have been around for generations. But just because someone does a lot, doesn't mean they do it well. You have been warned, avoid these lazy inconsiderate owners.

Approximate cost of services:
$2,000.00
3 of 3 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

In response to Susi Q from Hamilton. I am Rob Birnie Owner and President of Thos. R. Birnie and Sons, a company that has served the Hamilton and surrounding community for 90+ years. I feel that I must respond to your extremely negative and slanderous comments.

I am quite aware of the MANY times that you called our office with a problem. In actuality we went to your home on many occasions and explained why the restoration could not be completed as you thought it should be. We also explained that the situation regarding your porch was not created by our work. In fact I have many pages of notes for all the times you contacted us and the content of our conversations with you. We did let you know that the hole you speak of would need time to settle, sometimes for a whole season before it can be properly fixed, due to environmental factors. When we gave you the original estimate for the job at your home we gave you an expectation sheet that covered all of the work that would be done including restoration.

These 2 “tools” you speak of are my Operations Manager who has created thousands of satisfied customers and has been with our company for over 25 years and my Installation Supervisor who is a highly skilled and caring individual.

Our goal is always to exceed expectations and leave our customers completely satisfied with the work that was done. Every time you called our office you spoke to a person on the other end of the phone. We all tried our best to satisfy your immediate demands but it was obvious there was nothing we could do to make that happen. I realize that problems can occur, however I take great offense at your comments degrading my men, their work, and slandering my company with regards to a job that was completed and in fine working order. This was even confirmed by the City of Hamilton.

I have no problem letting other readers of this post know that we completed everything that we quoted and went back to your home every time in response to your calls. We will always come and make it right. That was the policy of my Great Grandfather, my Grandfather, my Father and Uncle, and it continues to be our family’s policy.
Also, I have no issue using my “real” name when writing something for the public to view, Susi Q.

Heather Stanley from Toronto
Heather Stanley from Toronto
5 reviews Toronto, ON
7/10

Fix 2 Toilets

Had my rented unit with a repeat problem of both toilets not flushing.
The service right from the telephone call through to the after-service follow up call has been very good. The plumber was on time, clean, helpful, courteous, took off his shoes, etc. I could not have asked for anything more from a customer service stand point.
My one complaint would be the pricing. $255 for 2 flapper valves and one handle seems a bit high to me. I was expecting in the $150 range, maybe $200. Since I know the valves at Canadian Tire to be around $20, the bill shocked me.
I would be happy to use them again, but would certainly shop around for better pricing before committing.

Approximate cost of services:
$255.00
Was this review helpful?
Peter from Burlington
Peter from Burlington
1 review Burlington, ON
10/10

Main line cleaning

The technician, David, was very thorough, explaining everything to me and offering me a list of the services that could be performed. I choose the service that included videoing the main line, which proved to be very advantageous as the line was clogged with grease, which we could see with the camera. David worked long and hard to clear the line as he and I did not want to have to use the hydrosrub option to clean the line, which is the most expensive option. He discovered we have 'bellies' in our line which meant hydroscrubbing would not have helped. After a couple of hours of effort, David managed to clear the line. Because of the bellies, I had a locate done which will aid in locating and repairing the bellies in the line.

I plan to have Birnie's do the plumbing work for us as we are about to start some kitchen renovations.

Approximate cost of services:
$800.00
Was this review helpful?
Linda from Hamilton
Linda from Hamilton
1 review Hamilton, ON
8/10

main drain back up

I am pleased with the service provided by David K. He was professional, informative, and wanted to make sure that I understood all the options before he started the work. He worked happily in a very stinky environment! He cleaned everything thoroughly and ensured that the work was complete. I know that the prices are set by the company, not the technician, and I find the prices high, but the quality of work is good.

Approximate cost of services:
$350.00
Was this review helpful?
Kelly from Hamilton
Kelly from Hamilton
1 review Hamilton, ON
10/10

Video Inspection & Drain cleaning

Our story begins with a horrible sewer smell wafting through our home and our drains making gurgling noises when we would flush. Birnie & Sons sent a technician within 24hrs. Bryce was professional, patient and informative. He completed the job in a few hours. He was fabulous to followup with us the following day. Thanks Bryce and Birnie & Sons!

Approximate cost of services:
$500.00
Was this review helpful?
Len Kamerman from Hamilton
Len Kamerman from Hamilton
1 review Hamilton, ON
10/10

Washer Hookup

David K turned a plumbing installation into an experience. He is highly professional, knowledgeable, and excited about plumbing. It was a real treat to have him install a washer hookup for us. He explained options regarding bringing the pipes straight up vs. a laundry box and made it a "plumbing work of art". I have never seen anyone so excited about plumbing, he was great! My wife thinks she heard him actually singing about the job as he was going about things.

I highly recommend Thos R Birnie & Sons and we would not hesitate to call again, and we will ask for David, to be sure.

Approximate cost of services:
$850.00
Was this review helpful?
Mike from Welland
Mike from Welland
1 review Welland, ON
10/10

Main Drain Clog

Very happy with the service call. Technician David K arrived on time and made sure I understood the options before proceeding with the work. He completed the job and cleaned the work area in acceptable time. There were no hidden costs and ensured my satisfaction with the work completed before leaving. For such a disgusting problem, David was a professional solution.

Approximate cost of services:
$450.00
Was this review helpful?
William Bell from Hamilton
William Bell from Hamilton
2 reviews Toronto, ON
10/10

sewer lining and back water vavle

We were very pleased with the work we received from all the employees . The had to dig up our laundry room floor, replace the sewer line,install a lining in the crawl space , install a back water valve and put in a new liner from the house to the city property line. The job was completed on time, the crews were professional, polite and very patient with our questions.

Approximate cost of services:
$9,000.00
Was this review helpful?
T
T
3 reviews Oakville, ON
10/10

Sump pump service/upgrade

This company is AMAZING! The emergency response is excellent and Bryce (who was at my home most recently) is not only incredibly skilled and professional, but also very reassuring in terms of dealing with a crisis. I highly recommend this company and suggest to all whom I know to become a "service member" with Thos Birnie because it is worth every cent up front for the great service you get going forward.

Approximate cost of services:
$1,000.00
Was this review helpful?
The reviews on this page are the subjective opinion of the Author and not of HomeStars Inc.

More about Birnie Thos R & Sons Ltd

Birnie Plumbing and Drains is a Family owned, full service Plumbing, Drain & Water Conditioning Company. Our Burlington, Hamilton and Oakville plumbing teams aim to provide the best customer experience through superior workmanship, quality products, and peace of mind service. From the early 1920’s to now we have been at ...
Company profile information is not moderated by HomeStars. Ask the contractor to verify before hiring.
Looking for Plumbing pros in Carlisle?