Is this your business? Receive leads and respond to reviews. Claiming is easy and free. Claim this business

A - Citadel Roofing

Roofing
Winnipeg MB R3C 4A3
Write a Review
Write a Review

Recommended Professionals

97%(73 reviews)
89%(5 reviews)
69%(8 reviews)
97%(73 reviews)
89%(5 reviews)
69%(8 reviews)
HomeStars
Roofing
A - Citadel Roofing
Star Score
Learn more about how StarScore uses a complex algorithm which considers a company's review ratings, responsiveness, reputation, and recency.

15%

This is the average rating based on homeowner reviews.
This indicates how long it's been since the last review.
Indicates how well a pro reacts to reviews and review-related interactions with Homeowners.
How well a company responds to Service Requests and Reviews.
Reviews by rating (past 12 months)

Reviews for A - Citadel Roofing

Average customer rating:
2.1 10 (10 reviews)

Sort by

fordachuk in Winnipeg
fordachuk in Winnipeg
0 reviews Winnipeg, MB
0/10

New Shingles

Hired Citadel to replace our shingles. 1 week after they finished we experienced water leaking into the house. Guy showed up the next day and put a crap load of tar along 1 seam of the roof. Again, had water dripping in every time it rained. Owner (Dave) would not return emails, calls and even a hand written letter until we threatened to go to BBB and look at legal action. then he proceeded to say we didn't know what we were talking about and it wasn't caused by his workmanship. Had 2 roof inspectors perform inspections and even 2 other roofing companies and they were able to find the problem instantly, but he still refused the honor his work. Finally hired another company to perform the repairs (as he just kept dodging us) and took legal action. Damages were awarded to us by the courts, but again, he refuses to communicate with us and has not paid a single $ of what the courts awarded us. Stay away, unprofessional and does not honor his workmanship.

Approximate cost of services:
$5,500.00
Was this review helpful?
scoochie2006  St. James
scoochie2006 St. James
4 reviews Winnipeg, MB
0/10

Roofing

Stay away. Guy is a hothead. Complained of shoddy workmanship and he threatened a lien on house if I didn't pay up. A few years after job and shingles are still coming off. I have to risk my life going up and renailing shingles back on.

Approximate cost of services:
$4,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Sheri from Headingley
Sheri from Headingley
1 review Headingley, MB
0/10

roofing

We have been trying to get this guy to come and fix the job that his company completed but he continually blows us off. Its been 4 years and every year that passes more leaking into the walls and windows. Just in the process of hiring a structural engineer for a report to take to court with us and hire him to appear with us if need be. We had no leaking in our home until this guy got his hands on it.

Approximate cost of services:
$32,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Wpghomeowner from Winnipeg
Wpghomeowner from Winnipeg
1 review Winnipeg, MB
0/10

Facia, soffit, eaves

Do not use this company. Do not let Dave fool you into thinking he is a nice guy (he is the owner and will do the estimate). We had some issues with some of the work done. He showed up at our house unannounced at dinner time wanting payment for the job even though it was not yet completed. He refused to believe that our eaves were leaking and when we showed him he rolled his eyes and began to yell and swear at us. After we got him out of the house, he tried to break down our door all while yelling on our front lawn that we don't know who he is and that he'll bring he** upon us. You also cannot get ahold of this company as it is a call centre that takes the calls and the owner (Dave) does not check emails regularly. It also took 8-9 weeks for the job to be completed, not the 3-4 he promised. We had to leave multiple messages and email to get a date. I am not confident that any work would be warrantied. The workmanship itself was decent and the contractors were very professional.

Approximate cost of services:
$5,800.00
Was this review helpful?
paul from Winnipeg
paul from Winnipeg
1 review Winnipeg, MB
10/10

roofing

Dave Peters Henry and crew were great-friendly respectful experienced-job completed to my expectations-competitive pricing and excellent customer service-recommended to my workplace and friends-concerns alleviated without issue-worry free- thank you and merci

Approximate cost of services:
$4,750.00
Was this review helpful?
Kurt from Winnipeg
Kurt from Winnipeg
1 review Winnipeg, MB
9/10

Exterior Siding

Citadel Exteriors honoured a two year old quote for extensive renovations to the back of my house that included removal of old wood siding and installation of new insulation, siding and widow cladding. They got my job done quickly and the house looks much better. Citadel was also able to fit my job into their schedule on short notice.

Approximate cost of services:
$5,000.00
Was this review helpful?
brad from Winnipeg
brad from Winnipeg
1 review Winnipeg, MB
0/10

roofing

hii got my roof done it was the worst experience i have ever had done. every time it rains i can fill my bathtub up with the rain water that enters my house. they didnt clean the mess up after the job was finished which also entered my neibours yards. please do not use this company for any work.

Approximate cost of services:
$5,000.00
Was this review helpful?
DIANE H from Winnipeg
DIANE H from Winnipeg
1 review Winnipeg, MB
0/10

roof and eaves troughs

worst company ever!!!! Do not hire them. They rip you off and won't come back to fix the damage they caused!! Will not acknowledge phone calls or letter of complaint. Beware!

Approximate cost of services:
$7,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Cathy in River Heights
Cathy in River Heights
1 review Winnipeg, MB
1/10

New roof, eaves and soffits

Roofers came quickly and job was finished within a few days. We had problems with a vent cover and they took forever to return. Numerous calls were made and not returned. Dave is the manager and did not provide any customer service. A relative of mine also had major problems to get them to return to fix some damage they caused. I would definitely NOT recommend this company.

Approximate cost of services:
$11,000.00
What could this company do to improve their services?
Call back customers promptly and finsh old jobs before beginning new ones.
Any advice to offer fellow homeowners facing a similar project?
Do not call this company!
Was this review helpful?
scoochie2006  St. James
scoochie2006 St. James
4 reviews Winnipeg, MB

First Review

1/10

reshingling

First, they were late. The siding was sitting on my driveway for 12 days until the roofers finally showed up, or should I say 1 roofer. It was the long weekend so he did worked on some of the roof on Saturday. Then the whole crew reappeared on Tuesday to start on the rest. They damaged 2 rainspouts by throwing the old shingles on top of them. I saw this when coming home from work so I had to remove the spouts myself. When the job was finally done a couple of days later (I only have a 1000 square foot home) they left without reinstalling 2 roof vents and repairing an eavestrough they damaged. I had to chase the contractor down to fix the problem. They also left me with a couple of pounds of roofing nails scattered all over my lawn and driveway. Lucky I borrowed a magnet and collected what I could up myself. You think they would clean up after themselves better. Lastly the appearance of the new shingles looked esthetically a little sloppy. Not a very neat job and a general lack of pride in workmanship.

Approximate cost of services:
$4,100.00
What could this company do to improve their services?
Any advice to offer fellow homeowners facing a similar project?
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful?
The reviews on this page are the subjective opinion of the Author and not of HomeStars Inc.

Is this your business?

Receive leads and respond to reviews.
Claiming is easy and free.

Claim this business
Company profile information is not moderated by HomeStars. Ask the contractor to verify before hiring.
Looking for Roofing pros in Transcona?