Reviews

10/10

This was the last of my home renovation projects and I definitely saved the best for last. After struggling through numerous contractors with our interior renovations we became very sceptical customers. We decided that at the end of the day you get what you pay for and we were going to finish our house off with a top end landscape company from Toronto with a great reputation. We were close to hiring one of these companies and I decided to bring in Fine Design for 1 last quote given the good reviews on homestars and the quality of work shown on their website. Braden was very professional, answered all of our questions promptly, quickly turned a very detailed quote and provided us with a lot of resources which allowed us to envision the final product. We decided to go with Fine Design and we have absolutely no regrets. Braden kept on top of the project unlike anyone else we have dealt with. If we ever had a concern he would get back to us incredibly fast. He also had great design suggestions along the way and we are 150% satisfied with the final product. This was not a small project and we are somewhat picky clients. The entire front yeard was landscaped, side yard and backyard. We had the driveway redone, the garage floor redone, all the stonework, planting, a 1000 sq ft deck, pergola, firepit, privacy fence, it goes on and on. Bottom line, if you want your landscaping done right and have incredible service levels long the way we would highly recommend Fine Design. Thanks so much Braden, we appreciate all your your team's hard work.

Approximate cost of services:
$0.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Thank you very much for your wonderful review. It was truly a pleasure to have the opportunity to complete your project. We are happy to hear that you are more than satisfied with both the workmanship and customer service experience. We take a lot of pride in providing our clients with the best service along with top quality workmanship. Thank you once again for your business and your kind words. We hope you continue to enjoy your backyard oasis and all of the other work that was completed. We look forward to staying in touch with you in the future.

Sincerely,

Braden White

1/10

Process started off smoothly with budget a little more than we wanted to spend (especially since we got ikea cabinets) but was willing to pay the money to get the job done right. Initially Tammy was great, very reponsive to all of our questions and concerns. 2 days into demo started getting worried about budget as we were over on almost every line item. I know that we picked some higher end stuff so I went along with it. Then we started getting bumped up on trades. Electriction was close to double the quote, plumber 3x the quote (she forgot we needed a gas line for a gas stove, and carpenter crew was 50% more). Like I said I knew that things can get over budget so I still did not complain, but the issues started when we saw the quality of work and the lack of professionalism from Tammy. Everything we mentioned that we wanted to get fixed Tammy answered with "the house was old" or "the carpenter is not a tile guy, and he is not a trim guy, or he is not a hardwood guy", but the try very hard and have alot of heart. I know that everyone worked hard but I am not paying people to work hard, I am paying people to get the job done right. They tried to fixed the stuff (flooring, wallpaper, drywall, etc) but most ended up in the same state as the carpenter obiously can't drywall either (gashes and uneven almost everywhere) To top things off Tammy decided that she did not want to have anything to do with the project after we asked to have things fixed so she did not talk to me or come to the house for the last 2 weeks of the job. She had her husband finish things up (who is a very nice man) but we were then left shopping for lights, tiles, kitchen finishes and other things(so we ended up doing her job and still paying her for it) All in all we ended up getting close to what we wanted but feel somewhat ripped off given the amount of work we had to do and the quality of the finished product. For the money we spent after the fact we would definately go with a more established company next time who knows what it's doing and does not run away as soon as people start questioning. I think that Tammy leaves much to be desired in terms of project management and overall knowledge of basic construction. It seemed like she viewed the job as a quick flip that she can do on a part-time basis. As you can see by Tammy's response this is what I had to deal with through the entire process. It's funny also how she mentioned throughout her response that she "paid" for a bunch of things. I sure you Tammy did not pay for anything at the end as I reimbursed her for everything. Anyways, nice to see that someone else spoke us as well and hopefully no one else gets burned by homegirl again. BTW, if anyone want her to stop working on your job as soon as you see the poor quality simply start asking questions and she will be out of sight in no time. Huge waste of time and money.

Approximate cost of services:
$68,000.00
3 of 3 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

As we all know there are 2 sides to every story, I feel the need to respond to Bernard as there are many inaccuracies in his account of what happened. I am rather surprised after the excellent service we gave him, to completion, that he still feels the need to attack. I did send in my partner to complete this job, who went over and above to try to make this customer happy. According to my partner, Bernard was very happy with everything, and even invited us out to enjoy the ‘finished product’ over a drink (I assume that offer is null and void:).

The cost of the plumber went up from the original estimate because we added a gas line to the cooktop, installed washer and dryer, new faucet in the laundry room and then had to move a water pipe which was exposed when moving a small wall. These were all additional. The decision to move this wall was made mid-project.

The electrician went up because he did double the work in the owner’s basement (not part of this project) he changed all aluminum wiring and basically rewired the basement as there were a number of issues – this was at the owner’s request. The electrician then added on another $800.00 for things he claims were not on original order (3 way switches, insulated pots etc). I immediately took responsibility for part of this and split the cost with the owner (he failed to mention this).

The carpenter didnt go up 50% or even close to that - but the homeowner knows this.

I sourced and bought all lighting, tile and everything for the kitchen to the smallest detail including cutlery inserts and tray dividers (I was not paid to do this and did this even after I was being treated most unkindly). The owner chose the fireplace surround tile, we cut it and were ready to install then they changed their mind and wanted us to return it. Obviously not an option at this point, they then said they would find their own and use the other, later, on another project. At this point I had paid for about $5000.00 in tile. I spent a full day shopping with the client for lighting, the client approved 2 lights which I then went and purchased, then the client went away for 10 days and asked me to choose and install the remaining 2 lights, they didn’t like these or one that they had approved (which had taken 4 hours to install). They asked me to go back and purchase another light for $699.00, at this point I was feeling less than confident in their intentions (Bernard had begun to send belligerent emails several times a day) and having spent an additional $3000.00 to pay for their washer and dryer which were delivered while they were out of town, I felt it was better for them to purchase any additional fixtures (we uninstalled the rejected ones and installed their new choices ).

I chose not to return to this job and to have my partner complete it as the attitude of the homeowner had shifted after they returned from vacation. It became increasingly obvious by the owners ‘nasty’ emails and my several attempts to explain our side (which were always answered from an attack stance) that a change was in order. As a business owner I made a decision to try to salvage the project/relationship by sending in another representative, at this point more than 90% of the work was completed. My partner went ‘over and above’ while managing the completion of the project. He worked along side the team cleaning out the owner’s garage beyond anything we were responsible for (while the owner stood and watched), he vacuumed out drawers and cupboards and washed floors in areas in which we were not working.

Overall it is an absolutely beautiful transformation, I am very proud of the work that my team and I did. There were issues of course, this was a large project, but we addressed them and assured the client we would give 100% until the job was complete. At no time did we ever imply that we were not there to address issues and finish the job.
I tried to explain the reasons for many of the decisions we had to make while the client was away - I felt inclined to explain, as honestly as possible, why some things came out the way they did. He seemed to resent this and saw it as excuses rather than a basic communication of ideas and opinions.

My costs, besides the personal ones like being hugely disappointed (I really liked this couple and took on this project like it was my own home, I really felt connected and put my heart into it), also included paying for the install of wallpaper chosen by the homeowner which turned out to be defective, I bought and paid for paper, installer and removal. All of these things were done in good faith, all for naught it turns out.

When the homeowner’s demeanor changed (immediately upon his return from a 10 day vacation) and he began treating me with distrust and insulting my integrity and intentions by email I was at first pretty disheartened, I didn’t start my dream business to do anything but enjoy the process and really help my clients realize their dream (homes). I painstakingly tried to get the project back on track by staying positive and solution oriented. To the team nothing had changed we were still moving forward doing our jobs, but on the other side it felt like we were dealing with a different person. I continued to try to rationalize with him and to try to get back to a place of trust and respect, but the ‘attack’ emails just kept coming. It began to take on all the characteristics of bullying, the situation became inappropriate and unacceptable. Finally after the 5th insulting email of yet another demoralizing day, I ‘reassigned’ this project to one of the most capable men I know, my partner Mario. He is a man with great integrity and character; he is the standard by which I measure other men. I am so proud to know he would never behave in this manner to anyone.

I am disappointed to note that when dealing with this particular homeowner, in what is a professional capacity, he failed to maintain a modicum of fairness and good business practice. In more than one way my partner towers over this ‘man’. . . OK I had to lighten the mood a little, we have a great life and I have had some of the most memorable experiences working on these projects, this one has to be chalked up to a very good lesson. Thanks for that Bernard, now I know it is not always the trades in the wrong - two sides to every renovation!

One last thing, this homeowner asked me several times if I had any nightmare clients, at that point I didn’t, but now I am happy to present him with that honor (your plaque is in the mail Bernard) it goes something like this: Homegirl’s Worst Client of the Year Award. Presented to Bernard (last name removed) in the spirit of ‘Never Again’. Good luck to you Bernard and remember in the big scheme of things ‘every little thing is going to be alright’. You have a beautiful home, life is good, enjoy.