Keating Roofing

Roofing
Mississauga ON L4X 1K5
Write a Review
Write a Review

Recommended Professionals

97%(49 reviews)
89%(9 reviews)
99%(175 reviews)
97%(49 reviews)
89%(9 reviews)
99%(175 reviews)
HomeStars
Roofing
Keating Roofing
Star Score
Learn more about how StarScore uses a complex algorithm which considers a company's review ratings, responsiveness, reputation, and recency.

60%

This is the average rating based on homeowner reviews.
This indicates how long it's been since the last review.
Indicates how well a pro reacts to reviews and review-related interactions with Homeowners.
How well a company responds to Service Requests and Reviews.
Reviews by rating (past 12 months)

Reviews for Keating Roofing

Average customer rating:
7.9 10 (86 reviews)

Sort by

Greg in North York
Greg in North York
1 review Toronto, ON
10/10

Replace roof and aluminum

I'm very happy with the work done on my home by Keating Roofing & Exteriors. They provided the most detailed quote and sat down in my home to walk me through the process - this made me feel most comfortable with Keating.
Vlad kept me in the loop regarding the timing and was always available to answer my questions.
They did exactly when they said they were going to do and all the employees were hard working, happy and respectful of my property.
I put a lot of pride into my home - when they left everything was absolutely spotless!
Even the neighbours had commented on how effiecient and organized the team was.
I was happily recommend this firm to my friends and family.

Approximate cost of services:
$23,500.00
What could this company do to improve their services?
Any advice to offer fellow homeowners facing a similar project?
Was this review helpful?
Anne  in North York
Anne in North York
1 review Toronto, ON
10/10

Exceeded my expectations in every regard!

Earlier this spring, we woke up on a rainy Friday to find water dripping from our ceiling. We called a few local roofing contractors, but Keating Roofing & Exteriors were the only ones that could help us in a timely manner. Matt and Ryan were on my roof within 2 hours with a tarp, providing us with an effective emergency repairs for a reasonable fee. This fee was to be refunded if a new roof was installed by Keating, and it was, which was a nice little bonus. They confirmed to us that we were certainly in need of a new roof, so we called around a got some estimates from companies we saw in the area. Vlad from Keating was by far the most professional, knowledgeable and thorough when inspecting my roof and attic and I felt most comfortable with this company. It didn't hurt that they have a project and sign on almost every street in my area and I see their trucks in the area everyday. The crew worked for 2 and a half days, replacing my roof and insulating my attic to make the living space more efficient and comfortable. Our property was cleaner when they left than before they started, and I could not find one scrap of garbage or a single nail anywhere. Amazing!

The price of this project was certainly not a small amount of money, but you certainly don't want the cheapest guys doing this type of work for you. The last roofer I hired got the job because of an attractive low price, and only 11 years later the roof was done. Take your time, do your homework, talk to references and make sure you invest wisely into your home.

Thanks Keating team! I will be sure to call you when we are ready to replace our windows and front door.

Approximate cost of services:
$30.00
Was this review helpful?
JAD in Toronto
JAD in Toronto
1 review Toronto, ON
10/10

Roof replacement, roof repairs, and have recommended them repeatedly!

Keating re-roofed my semi-detached house in Toronto. They were in and out quickly, cleaned up very carefully and were respectful of my property at all times. The craftsmanship was excellent, but what was even more important was the customer service. Any issues / questions I had were addressed with priority and a strong focus on customer satisfaction, both by the rep I was dealing with (David), and the office if the questions needed to be redirected. When I moved north of the city (Caledon), I was so happy with their service in the GTA that I had them do work up there on my new place as well. I've recommended them on several occasions, and will continue to do so, although they are most appropriate for work in the immediate GTA.

Approximate cost of services:
$11,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Stephen B in Toronto
Stephen B in Toronto
1 review Toronto, ON
10/10

Full home exterior renovation

We hired Keating Roofing to do a full exterior renovation including a new roof, attic insulation, venting, eavestroughs, soffits, lighting, cedar, windows and stucco. The project was recently completed and we couldn't be happier with the results! Now our house is the stand out on the street.

Everyone from project managers to contractors were very friendly and professional at all times. All my calls, e-mails and questions were addressed in a timely manner and all add-ons and contingency items were quoted in writing before proceeding.

All representatives of Keating seemed invested and interested in our (the clients) happiness with the results and were able to provide good design ideas that helped us to make our final design decisions. I would absolutely recommend Keating for exterior finishes and they will be the first people we call if we decide to do more work, although there's not much left they didn't already do!

The carpenter's work with the ceder was a real stand out for me, it completely changed the look of our house, closer to its original 1920's appearance.

Approximate cost of services:
$43,000.00
What could this company do to improve their services?
Any advice to offer fellow homeowners facing a similar project?
Was this review helpful?
Mark in Mississauga
Mark in Mississauga
1 review Toronto, ON
10/10

Major roof reworking

We contacted a few companies to get quotes, but none would do the work that we needed done , except for Keating. Ours was not just a reshingling job, but involved extending our roof to add overhangs so that we could get proper circulation in our attic. It was stiflingly hot in the summer, enough so, that you could feel the heat coming down from the ceiling inside the house. Besides the overhangs, we also wanted a porch roof, as we had none, as well as the two chimney stacks removed( they weren't being used ) down to the roofline.

Matt came over and went over what we wanted as well as costs and when payments were due, with the bulk of the cost being payed near the end, when the work was done. When the guys came over to start the work, they didn't fool around. The bulk of it was done within a week. We did have to wait for certain finishes to arrive, but that was to be expected and we were told as much. We even had a particular style we were going for on our porch that didn't quite turn out the way we wanted and they redid it to our specifications. We found them very professional and pleasing to work with and they provided a wide range of services that the other roofing companies did not. We would definitely recommend them to any friends or family that needed their service and would call on them again if needed.

Approximate cost of services:
$30,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Jeff in Toronto
Jeff in Toronto
10 reviews Toronto, ON
6/10

Roof, Windows & Minor Masonry Work

I chose Keating based on the positive reviews on the Homestars website, an in-person meeting and based on the fact that they bill themselves as a one-stop shop for exterior work -- including windows, doors and masonry.
My experience with the company, however, was quite mixed. As with others, I got a detailed proposal for the roof work. This seemed impressive. However, there was virtually nothing in it about other components of the project -- new windows throughout, a storm door, repairs to the top of a deteriorating brick fire wall. At the moment, I didn't think that much of it. However, this was a mistake. That said, the night we met to review the proposal, we mentioned two additional deliverables that we hadn't mentioned earlier -- work associated with framing the interior of the bathroom window and creating an access point to the house's attic. Matt said something vague about how doing both of these things wouldn't be a problem. But we never got an updated proposal with updated costing. The absence of this, combined with a lack of detail on the non-roofing elements of the project ended up really negatively affecting my experience with Keating.
The roofing and masonry components of the project went quickly and smoothly. The crew did the job very quickly and well. They left the site very clean. However Matt didn't add the attic access request to the docket and so this wasn't completed. Then the window replacement came. It took A MONTH AND A HALF for this part of the job to get done -- way longer than most professional window installation companies would take. About a month into the work, I contacted Matt about the completion of the project -- which comprised of finishing the interior trims and sills damaged by removing the old windows, re-installing the storm door they put in (which was too short for the opening) and the interior bathroom window framing. He insisted that we meet during office hours at my home (which took me away from work). I then had a conversation with him where he said he'd have the interior trims & sills done the next day but would require someone to be on-site (again, another day for me away from the office). He also gave vague answers on the timeline for the bathroom framing work, adjusting the door so it fit properly and the attic access issue. His excuse? "We just don't get the same volumes for this type of work as we do for the roofs." That's unacceptable! Why couldn't they have managed my expectations on timelines at the outset?
It's also around this time that I am having other contractors quoting me on a separate brick restoration project. Matt somehow finds out (perhaps because one of the contractors shows up while the Keating guys are on site) and tries to pitch Keating for the contract -- a bit obnoxious & amatuerish given the excuses I've endured already.
Regardless, the following day I stay home from work and the worker who was to do the interior trims & sills NEVER SHOWS UP! I email Matt at about 1pm and he tells me to call the Keating office. I was livid that he was expecting me to do this. The point of going with a company that offered a full range of services was to avoid the air-traffic control of project management. It turns out that this worker was double booked.
Finally, this leads me to write an email to the principals at Keating -- John, Justin -- airing my deep disappointment. From here on in, I deal with John. I like John a lot better as the project point person -- he is direct and forthright in his communications (no BS Dale Carnegie crap). Part of this is telling me that if I want attic access this will cost $1200 more and the bathroom window will cost another $846, plus tax. I decline the attic access and eat the cost of the bathroom window, which they actually do a very good job on. However, the job only completes about three weeks later.
So in the end the most of the projects were done, and what was done was done well, but I had to nag, I had to compromise my expectations, I had to do A LOT of waiting and I had to pay more than I was quoted. Was this a good experience? Not really.

Approximate cost of services:
$25,000.00
What could this company do to improve their services?
Any advice to offer fellow homeowners facing a similar project?
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful?
amartin_7 in Toronto
amartin_7 in Toronto
1 review Mississauga, ON
10/10

Roof System Excellence

Keating delivered top notch service from day 1 Matt reviewing the scope of work with options to finished roof.Definitely gave comfort understanding my costs and benefits of their superior roof system technologies. The age of the home required some additional venting due to no soffit vents which Matt highlighted and creatively added enhancing the the performance of the roof and benefiting the interior house temperature.
They added a beautiful skylight seamlessly which transformed the interior of the house and gave ventilation and needed light.The workmanship was excellent top notch and right on schedule. The followup by the owner verified the workmanship and my satisfaction. I highly recommend Keating to deliver the best Roofing systems solutions.

Approximate cost of services:
$15,000.00
Was this review helpful?
aubreyinmotion in Toronto
aubreyinmotion in Toronto
3 reviews Toronto, ON
10/10

Flat and diagonal roof replacement, with upper deck removal and replacement

My wife and I had been renovating our home for a couple of months before engaging Keating Roofing to re-shingle one of our diagonal roofs, completely replace a large flat roof area, and disassemble and then reassemble a large wooden upper deck in order to access the flat roof. After 11 years of a slow, inconsistent leak from the area (which fortunately dripped into a shower stall!), and having dealt with literally at least a dozen roofers over the past decade who had different theories and about the root cause of the leak and loads of creative ideas about how to fix the leak, not one could actually fix the problem! Many suggested removing the deck, but none presented the option of disassembling it, storing it on our upper roof while the roof repair was conducted, and then reassembling the perfectly good wood... none expect for Keating that is. Enter John Keating, President of Keating Roofing, son of the company's founder. Professional, articulate, reliable, and with a crew that went way beyond our expectations, especially after our recent slew of negative experiences that we had with a number of reputedly "professional" contractors, we could not be happier with our Keating experience. The quote package was phenomenal, and personalized down to the finite detail, including a colour photo of our photo on the front of the 10+ page document. John's team showed up early every day, were courteous and efficient, CLEANED UP every day, and did a job that appears to be second to none. My wife and I are now Keating advocates, and will be lifelong customers. There will be only one roofing and exteriors company we will turn to and recommend in the years to come. THANK YOU Keating for restoring our faith in truly professional contractors. >>:-)

Approximate cost of services:
$11,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Parv
Parv
8 reviews Toronto, ON
10/10

Roof Work - ridge vent, skylight install, sun tunnel...

Great experience with this company. Everyone I dealt with was professional and very knowledgeable. I had a bunch of things done to my roof: ridge vent, skylights, sun tunnel.. all installed with no issues, quality of work was top notch. I would highly recommend going with this crew for any roofing needs.

Approximate cost of services:
$0.00
Was this review helpful?
Matt in Toronto
Matt in Toronto
1 review Toronto, ON
10/10

Good work, good pricing, good support

My home in Toronto is over a hundred years old, and has seen many homeowner-done "improvements". When my roof began to leak, I contacted a number of companies, but Keating provided, by far, the most reasonable and well thought-out estimate. They did an excellent job, removing the six (yes, six!) previous layers of shingles from my roof, and replaced them with a new shingled roof. After, there was a minor bit of follow up, and Keating responded in a timely way, supporting the work they'd done without charging me extra.

Approximate cost of services:
$3,000.00
Was this review helpful?
The reviews on this page are the subjective opinion of the Author and not of HomeStars Inc.

More about Keating Roofing

Keating Roofing is a family run organization and thrives to deliver 100% customer satisfaction. With over 45 years of roofing Practice and ongoing training we are fully committed to roofing excellence. Keating Roofing is fully insured and all of our employees are covered by workers compensation should anyone be injured ...
Company profile information is not moderated by HomeStars. Ask the contractor to verify before hiring.
Looking for Roofing pros in Toronto?